Coarse information and finite rank obstructions for flat lattice Hodge forms
Citable version that has not completed AIRR screening. Not peer reviewed. Screening record
We study how finite observations and finite-rank repairs can restore coercivity for unit-spacing flat lattice Hodge forms. An explicitly constructed real Fourier band gives necessary output-dimension budgets, including tangent obstructions for differentiable nonlinear observations. Singular Schur compatibility explains why kernel nonnegativity alone is insufficient. Positive results include scalar and matrix critical inverse-moment bounds for global spectral observations, exact finite prescribed-mean penalty thresholds, and constructive spatial means. For coefficients depending on any k < D coordinate directions, we construct actual disjoint rectangular averages with penalty coefficient K = c and the critical target-order observation budget. The construction derives local energy control from the coefficients and charges a balanced base tree through its invariant directions; it handles odd sizes and singleton cells. At least one exactly invariant coordinate remains required by this argument. An explicit corollary of the existing threshold construction handles arbitrary arrangements of scalar coefficient values 1 and H: the actual critical moment gives target-order rectangular means with the same global penalty coefficient K=c. Complementary examples distinguish successful observations from minimum-coefficient, full-tree, point-support and strong Green-moment certificates. The latter have matching all-rectangle certificate-cost regimes. A weaker detour exclusion and an explicit coexact parity example delimit an additional local comparison route. Further exact boundary-energy calculations rule out uniformly controlled exact trace extension based only on internal energy, including near-one critical moments, and, in D ≥ 4, a size-independent sum of separately minimized harmonic costs over disjoint rectangles. The discrepancy also occupies a growing-dimensional space, ruling out uniformly bounded-rank repairs of that particular comparison. The underlying binary family nevertheless admits the constructive partition. Local shell estimates lower the inverse-moment exponent from D/2 to (D-1)/2 with a necessary thickness cost; the thickness-uniform D/2 estimate and sharp local counterexamples are grouped with them. A coefficient-selected unit shell supplies actual disjoint face means. Two matched quantitative counterexamples distinguish discarded canonical interfaces from an actual off-center annular slowdown; successful full-cube means on both families keep the unrestricted question separate. Complete analytical proofs and separately pinned formal endpoints and finite diagnostic records are distinguished throughout. Classical methods are attributed, and originality remains subject to further comparison. The unrestricted critical rectangular problem is open. No interacting or continuum Yang–Mills mass gap is asserted.
Preview PDF on this page v12
Uses your browser's PDF viewer. Open the PDF directly if a preview is unavailable.
Cite this paper
Lluis Eriksson (2026). Coarse information and finite rank obstructions for flat lattice Hodge forms. AIRR.SCIENCE, ARR-2026-7EPM3V3DP796BBRR, v12. https://airr.science/papers/ARR-2026-7EPM3V3DP796BBRR/versions/v12/ Research preprint; ARR-2026-7EPM3V3DP796BBRR v12. Not peer reviewed by AIRR. Working paper; not admitted to the AIRR accepted collection.
Use this version link to cite the manuscript you read. A Working paper label means the version has not completed AIRR screening. AIRR screening is not journal peer review. Import BibTeX, RIS or CSL JSON into your reference manager to apply a citation style.
Version history
The paper identifier remains stable. Each version has its own immutable release, timestamp and version identifier.
- v15 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v14 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v13 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v12 · major revision · source snapshot available · viewing
- v11 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v10 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v9 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v8 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v7 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v6 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v5 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v4 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v3 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v2 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v1 · source snapshot available
Revision statement
Major revision. Group actual selected unit-shell observations with matching canonical internal repair-rank and offcenter annular losses; preserve whole-domain/coexact/physical distinctions and original source rejection/correction. First numerical review and prominent Brudnyi bibliographic clarification accompany unchanged assessed PDF.
Verification record
- Frontier-model screening
- Not assessed
- Source integrity
- Pass
- Bibliographic integrity
- Not assessed
- Reproducibility
- Not assessed
- Lean 4
- Not assessed
Recorded under ERIKSSON-EXACT-ARTIFACT-20261031. AIRR verification and screening are not peer review.
AI assistance statement
Codex prepared this integrated95page exact manuscript. One first declared exactPDF221B AI assessment: scientific importance4.00/10,4overall stars; five criteria correctness4,rigor4,novelty3,significance3,reproducibility3, recommendation minor_revision, no principal-theorem-invalidating material objection found. Complete original report and all adverse findings retained. Page92 Brudnyi scope wording needs qualification: AppendixI RemarkI.2 also treats boundary-touching dyadic inner cubes. A prominent public companion acknowledges this; frozen assessed PDF unchanged, no regrade. Reviewer is OpenAI Codex, system-described as based on GPT-6; exact served backend/effort unknown. Prior Perron211/assessment217 context and current historical score exposure, shared account/filesystem/provider/history disclosed; no blindness or verified independence. Full text95pages,16contacts,13individual pages read; no scientific/Lean/build replay by reviewer. No inherited score, target score, resampling, human peer review or editorial acceptance. Originality, historical verification, unrestricted rectangle and physical continuum questions remain open.
Frontier-model screening
Status: not_assessed. Any listed reports correspond to this exact version under ARR-SCREEN-1.0; no absent assessment is represented as a pass.
Model assessments and review context
- Distinct models
- 1
- Range
- 4.00–4.00
- Method
- bounded capability-weighted mean · exact version only
Limited evidence · 0/1 benchmark matches. This is an evidence description, not a probability of correctness.
Only one distinct model; One provider; shared blind spots possible; Fresh blinded review context not documented for every model; Benchmark match incomplete; Adverse reports or unresolved objections require editorial disposition
OpenAI · Codex, described by exposed instructions as an agent based on GPT-6; exact served backend and effort unknown · unknown · review context: unknown4.00
Recommendation: Minor Revision · Material objections: 0
The complete 95-page exactPDF221B presents credible finite lattice estimates, rank obstructions, signed-penalty examples and adaptive geometric bounds. The new coefficient-selected unit shell and matching off-center-hole loss are meaningful local additions. I found no principal-theorem contradiction under the stated hypotheses. Minor revision is warranted for a specific Brudnyi Appendix I scope qualification and clearer contribution/dependency mapping. Classical ingredients are substantial, exact priority remains uncertain, and neither the unrestricted rectangle adapter nor a physical continuum result is established. This is a first declared assessment of B with retained prior participation disclosed, not independent human peer review.
- Correctness confidence
- Full current text and analytical checks support the finite claims, including the new shell and boundary examples. No principal-theorem counterexample was found. No formal or executable replay was performed.
- Rigor
- Detailed proofs retain orientation, rank, kernel cross-term, multiplicity and boundary hypotheses. The route-specific conclusions are mostly well scoped; global rectangle and continuum conclusions remain open.
- Novelty
- Explicit lattice examples and sharp certificate distinctions are plausible contributions, but their ingredients are classical and exact priority remains unestablished. Brudnyi Appendix I needs a scope qualification.
- Significance
- Useful specialist progress in finite lattice coercivity and coarse information. The new local adapter and sharp counterexamples do not solve the unrestricted rectangle problem or a physical continuum mass gap.
- Reproducibility
- Frozen artifact hashes and complete readable derivations aid checking. Source builds, formal dependency closure, manifests and finite experiments were not replayed; supplied audit and build claims were not independently authenticated.
Strengths
- Exact rank-nullity and low-frequency constructions distinguish coarse information from coercivity without hiding volume dependence.
- Singular Schur and signed-penalty examples retain the kernel cross-term condition and identify failures of kernel-only reasoning.
- Critical-moment and finite Sobolev arguments track lattice normalization, reflection multiplicity, thin geometry and admissible coefficient classes.
- Section 40.1 selects a unit shell from the original critical moment and obtains bounded face rank with the correct scale.
- Sections 40.2–40.3 distinguish failed internal or punctured-domain certificates from successful full-energy bounds and provide matching orders.
Weaknesses
- The global coefficient-selected rectangle adapter remains open; the new shell lemma supplies no complete global rank and covering accounting.
- Priority of the exact refinements is not established by the targeted primary-source checks, while the main methods have extensive classical antecedents.
- The 95-page accumulation of examples and provenance narrative obscures the hierarchy of new theorems and their dependencies.
- Formal endpoints, source build claims and selected finite runs have not been replayed in this assessment and do not certify the full manuscript.
Potential errors
- Page 92 describes Brudnyi Appendix I through a strictly interior dyadic cube, but Remark I.2 also covers boundary-touching dyadic inner cubes. Qualify this description and distinguish dyadic geometry from the weighted-energy adapter; no current principal theorem is thereby refuted.
- Extending scalar axis tents or off-center Neumann-domain examples to coexact or divergence-constrained fields would require additional proof; that extension was not established here.
- Interpreting route-specific internal-energy or punctured-domain failures as an unrestricted full-cube rectangle impossibility would exceed the proved quantifiers.
Strong novelty candidates
- Explicit coexact/rank constructions and singular signed-penalty examples in the specified finite lattice normalization.
- Quantitative separation of strong certificate costs, weak counting, retained interfaces and full-energy coercivity.
- Coefficient-selected unit-shell face estimates with original D/2-moment accounting and scale-matching lower examples.
- Matching canonical weak-axis repair-rank order and matching off-center-hole Poincare loss, each with carefully delimited scope.
Unresolved material objections
None reported.
arr:assessment:06f8a224-2dcb-4693-b475-ba4ad4626abb · prompt ARR-ASSESS-1.0 · response SHA-256 50bc867123fcbd8ce4de5e75aaa68ea4b9b6ef6a0d4ca52a2575efe88d12a989 · canonical PDF SHA-256 78bcb10ac82b7b920281542a311a28bf70132c73a4a1dbacf90c62b62eb9bf83
OpenAI · Codex, described by exposed instructions as an agent based on GPT-6; exact served backend and effort unknown
Original AI-only score: 4 / 10 · Scientific importance0-10; overall1-10; five criteria1-5
minor_revision
The complete 95-page exactPDF221B presents credible finite lattice estimates, rank obstructions, signed-penalty examples and adaptive geometric bounds. The new coefficient-selected unit shell and matching off-center-hole loss are meaningful local additions. I found no principal-theorem contradiction under the stated hypotheses. Minor revision is warranted for a specific Brudnyi Appendix I scope qualification and clearer contribution/dependency mapping. Classical ingredients are substantial, exact priority remains uncertain, and neither the unrestricted rectangle adapter nor a physical continuum result is established. This is a first declared assessment of B with retained prior participation disclosed, not independent human peer review.
Backend identity: unknown. One first declared numerical exact95pagePDFB assessment. All95textpages,16contacts and13individual pages read. Prior Perron211/assessment217 participation retained, historical score exposed on currentpage45. Shared account/filesystem/provider/history, hidden backend/effort and independence unknown. No scientific/build/Lean replay by reviewer, inherited grade, resampling or human peer review. Full original report preserves every adverse finding including Brudnyi RemarkI.2. Public companion qualifies page92 while exactPDF remains unchanged.
Report captured · Exact PDF SHA-256 78bcb10ac82b7b920281542a311a28bf70132c73a4a1dbacf90c62b62eb9bf83
- report-hashes.json · SHA-256
4b42053c754b461dc195bf9ec7ad93b7de37647d72b37c4b9813739bc59a5ec8 - response.json · SHA-256
f185871e7b4afb7d71dff8bde8292a37d7c223c6cf2ece6554909646ef53a8d1 - review-context.json · SHA-256
3e95861ddda8a740b22081154ee6da567a11c8d7b44400c049bac209b1ed90f5 - scientific-review.txt · SHA-256
d8265f27c1e72ee5112d816e8c041f41607da95d3c7c1a1786bce5cabf0625f7
A model assessment is not peer review or a correctness certificate. AIRR preserves disagreement, exact-version provenance and later reassessments.
Editorial disclosure
Working paper, not editorial acceptance or human peer review. Actual clean eligible linked native receipt and exact author permission verified separately. One genuine exact-PDF numerical AI assessment and complete original report retained. Bibliographic qualification is public; frozen PDF wording remains unchanged. Priority, independence, comprehensive historical execution and unrestricted/physical questions remain unestablished.