Coarse information and finite rank obstructions for flat lattice Hodge forms
Citable version that has not completed AIRR screening. Not peer reviewed. Screening record
We study how finite observations and finite-rank repairs can restore coercivity for unit-spacing flat lattice Hodge forms. An explicitly constructed real Fourier band gives necessary output-dimension budgets, including tangent obstructions for differentiable nonlinear observations. Singular Schur compatibility explains why kernel nonnegativity alone is insufficient. Positive results include scalar and matrix critical inverse-moment bounds for global spectral observations, exact finite prescribed-mean penalty thresholds, and constructive spatial means. For coefficients depending on any k < D coordinate directions, we construct actual disjoint rectangular averages with penalty coefficient K = c and the critical target-order observation budget. The construction derives local energy control from the coefficients and charges a balanced base tree through its invariant directions; it handles odd sizes and singleton cells. At least one exactly invariant coordinate remains required by this argument. An explicit corollary of the existing threshold construction handles arbitrary arrangements of scalar coefficient values 1 and H: the actual critical moment gives target-order rectangular means with the same global penalty coefficient K=c. Complementary examples distinguish successful observations from minimum-coefficient, full-tree, point-support and strong Green-moment certificates. The latter have matching all-rectangle certificate-cost regimes. A weaker detour exclusion and an explicit coexact parity example delimit an additional local comparison route. Further exact boundary-energy calculations rule out uniformly controlled exact trace extension based only on internal energy, including near-one critical moments, and, in D ≥ 4, a size-independent sum of separately minimized harmonic costs over disjoint rectangles. The discrepancy also occupies a growing-dimensional space, ruling out uniformly bounded-rank repairs of that particular comparison. The underlying binary family nevertheless admits the constructive partition. Complete analytical proofs and separately pinned formal endpoints and finite diagnostic records are distinguished throughout. Classical methods are attributed, and originality remains subject to further comparison. The unrestricted critical rectangular problem is open. No interacting or continuum Yang–Mills mass gap is asserted.
Preview PDF on this page v10
Uses your browser's PDF viewer. Open the PDF directly if a preview is unavailable.
Cite this paper
Lluis Eriksson (2026). Coarse information and finite rank obstructions for flat lattice Hodge forms. AIRR.SCIENCE, ARR-2026-7EPM3V3DP796BBRR, v10. https://airr.science/papers/ARR-2026-7EPM3V3DP796BBRR/versions/v10/ Research preprint; ARR-2026-7EPM3V3DP796BBRR v10. Not peer reviewed by AIRR. Working paper; not admitted to the AIRR accepted collection.
Use this version link to cite the manuscript you read. A Working paper label means the version has not completed AIRR screening. AIRR screening is not journal peer review. Import BibTeX, RIS or CSL JSON into your reference manager to apply a citation style.
Version history
The paper identifier remains stable. Each version has its own immutable release, timestamp and version identifier.
- v15 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v14 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v13 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v12 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v11 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v10 · major revision · source snapshot available · viewing
- v9 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v8 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v7 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v6 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v5 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v4 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v3 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v2 · major revision · source snapshot available
- v1 · source snapshot available
Revision statement
Major revision. Growing-rank boundary comparison diagnostic and explicitly deduplicated earlier binary threshold corollary;84page integrated successor. Exact-PDF4.20/10,4stars; complete report/allO1-O5 retained. Unrestricted problem open.
Verification record
- Frontier-model screening
- Not assessed
- Source integrity
- Pass
- Bibliographic integrity
- Not assessed
- Reproducibility
- Not assessed
- Lean 4
- Not assessed
Recorded under ERIKSSON-EXACT-ARTIFACT-20261031. AIRR verification and screening are not peer review.
AI assistance statement
Codex prepared this manuscript. One newly declared exact84pagePDF AI assessment: scientific importance4.20/10,4overall stars, criteria4/4/3/3/3. Original recommendation: suitable scoped working paper, specialist revision before journal acceptance. All five objections O1-O5 and complete original report retained. Native technical projection uses major_revision because its schema requires that enum when material objections remain; no score or substantive finding is changed. Reviewer OpenAI Codex based on GPT-6; exact served backend/effort unexposed, shared account/filesystem, no verified independence. No inherited rating, human peer review or editorial acceptance. General rectangular and interacting/continuum questions remain open.
Frontier-model screening
Status: not_assessed. Any listed reports correspond to this exact version under ARR-SCREEN-1.0; no absent assessment is represented as a pass.
Model assessments and review context
- Distinct models
- 1
- Range
- 4.20–4.20
- Method
- bounded capability-weighted mean · exact version only
Limited evidence · 0/1 benchmark matches. This is an evidence description, not a probability of correctness.
Only one distinct model; One provider; shared blind spots possible; Fresh blinded review context not documented for every model; Benchmark match incomplete; Adverse reports or unresolved objections require editorial disposition
OpenAI · Codex (GPT-6-based; exact served backend and effort unexposed) · unknown · review context: shared4.20
Recommendation: Major Revision · Material objections: 5
A strong specialist dossier of finite flat-lattice observation budgets, global critical inverse-moment sufficiency, restricted actual rectangular constructions and route-specific counterexamples. No blocking mathematical counterexample to central claims was found in this limited review. The k<D construction and growing-dimensional trace discrepancy are particularly substantive. Binary means are explicitly an earlier threshold corollary. General rectangular and physical continuum questions remain open; no acceptance or independent verification is implied. Original free-text recommendation: suitable_scoped_working_paper_specialist_revision_before_journal_acceptance. Native major_revision is the conservative schema projection retaining all five material objections, not another assessment.
- Correctness confidence
- Central arguments survived full text reading and focused analytic checks; no formal rebuild or scientific replay.
- Rigor
- Self-contained finite proofs with explicit normalization, quantifiers, geometry and analytic/formal boundaries; formula-domain clarification remains.
- Novelty
- Specific constructions and diagnostic families are plausible incremental contributions; mechanisms are classical and priority is unestablished.
- Significance
- Useful specialist flat-lattice results; general rectangle problem and interacting/continuum bridges remain open.
- Reproducibility
- Immutable evidence locators and careful reported run scopes; only PDF/text identity and supplied images were checked here, no fresh recipe/build execution.
Strengths
- Actual maps, positive-start forms, coexact potentials and disjoint partitions are constructed.
- Necessary rank, spectral observations, rectangle means, penalty coefficients and certificate costs are distinguished.
- Theorem 35.1 derives local energy from coefficients and charges terminal descendants with at least one invariant direction.
- Boundary comparison failures are separated from successful selectable binary observations.
- Formal endpoints, analytic proofs, finite diagnostics and historical exact-artifact assessments retain distinct status.
Weaknesses
- Incremental originality and exhaustive priority comparison remain unresolved.
- No fresh formal compilation, scientific replay or full archive/dependency audit was performed in this assessment.
- Exact invariance remains required by the partial-coordinate tree argument.
- The general fully variable critical rectangular question and interacting/continuum physical dictionary remain open.
- The integrated 84-page presentation contains repeated operational context and historical referent ambiguity.
Potential errors
- {"description": "Domain-sensitive Kmin ambiguity: the displayed fraction is correct on the mean-zero subspace; a full-space reading also requires max with c.", "exact_test": "tau=1 gives displayed c-alpha<c, but f=1 forces K>=c.", "location": "Section 29.1 p.58", "status": "clarification needed; not a demonstrated failure of the central theorems"}
Strong novelty candidates
- {"basis": "Actual k<D critical inverse-mass rectangular construction with K=c and balanced invariant-direction charging.", "priority_established": false, "result": "Theorem 35.1"}
- {"basis": "All-rectangle strong Green-certificate cost phase diagram, separate from observation rank.", "priority_established": false, "result": "Theorem 32.1"}
- {"basis": "Near-one-moment extension and growing-dimensional independently minimized trace discrepancy families.", "priority_established": false, "result": "Proposition 37.2, Theorem 37.3, Proposition 38.1"}
- {"basis": "Actual-coexact prescribed-mean penalty witnesses and critical residue transfer as model-specific realizations.", "priority_established": false, "result": "Section 28.7"}
Unresolved material objections
- {"blocks_scoped_working_paper": false, "falsifier_or_resolution": "Compare exact hypotheses/conclusions/constants with closest weighted approximation/capacity and adaptive partition results. A prior theorem giving the same finite coefficient-to-rectangle count falsifies novelty.", "id": "O1", "location": "Sections 1, 17.1, 23, 28.2, 34, 35.4, 37.4, 38.4; Theorem 35.1 and Proposition 38.1", "objection": "Targeted classical-method comparisons do not establish incremental priority of the specific restricted construction and diagnostic families.", "severity": "material originality limitation"}
- {"blocks_scoped_working_paper": false, "falsifier_or_resolution": "Reconstruct exact pinned sources and audit printed theorem hypotheses against dependency readouts and raw outputs. Extra axioms, changed statements, omitted hypotheses or mismatched accepted outputs falsify the respective evidence assertion.", "id": "O2", "location": "Sections 13–14, 24.5, 25, 28.8, 29.5, 34.2, 35.4; Section 36.3", "objection": "This round did not rebuild formal sources, inspect all archived logs/dependencies, or replay scientific diagnostics. Section 36's diagnostics are explicitly unexecuted.", "severity": "material verification limitation"}
- {"blocks_scoped_working_paper": false, "falsifier_or_resolution": "For rectangles derive a valid all-coefficient partition/count/penalty or defeat every permitted partition on an admissible fixed-M family. Physical claims require proved form/domain/scaling and continuum bridges.", "id": "O3", "location": "Section 27; Sections 35.4, 37.3, 38.3–38.4", "objection": "Fully variable intermediate coefficients and interacting/continuum physical conclusions remain open. Exact invariance is essential to the presented tree charge; binary excision does not cover intermediate levels.", "severity": "material scope limit"}
- {"blocks_scoped_working_paper": false, "falsifier_or_resolution": "For tau=1, the fraction equals c-alpha<c while the constant field requires K>=c. Label the domain explicitly, or state full-space Kmin=max(c, displayed fraction).", "id": "O4", "location": "Section 29.1, p.58, Kmin display following analysis on e-perp", "objection": "The displayed minimum is a mean-zero optimum. If read on the full space it omits the constant-mode floor K>=c.", "severity": "minor but concrete formula-domain ambiguity"}
- {"blocks_scoped_working_paper": false, "falsifier_or_resolution": "Provide one authoritative chronology and identify each unchanged historical artifact explicitly, retaining all adverse records. Consolidate evidence-status navigation.", "id": "O5", "location": "Section 26 p.45 versus opening guide; Sections 22.6 and 23.6; repeated evidence narratives", "objection": "The integrated manuscript retains v8/v9 chronology and inherited frozen-artifact phrasing that can confuse current versus historical referents.", "severity": "submission presentation limitation"}
arr:assessment:d462a367-583b-4df3-94bb-a27c061e7955 · prompt ARR-ASSESS-1.0 · response SHA-256 421baa9d2a2e707fb5c03b9d03fbc9e3baea7eb796f66239f18dcf91a59f4a7f · canonical PDF SHA-256 c90f30000d0e723b88af0e9402f1d3e697077a8c9d15f131082e7627ea06b27c
OpenAI · Codex (GPT-6-based; exact served backend and effort unexposed)
Original AI-only score: 4.2 / 10 · AIRR Millennium0-10 scientific importance;4overall stars; five separate criteria4/4/3/3/3 on1-5
suitable_scoped_working_paper_specialist_revision_before_journal_acceptance
Exact84pagePDF4.20/10 and4overall stars. AllO1-O5 and complete raw report/response/context retained. General rectangular/physical problems open; binary means explicitly an earlier threshold corollary. Separate clarifications do not amend/regrade the frozen PDF.
Backend identity: unknown. One declared exact-PDF review. Shared account/filesystem and delegated orchestration; exact backend/effort and independence unexposed or unverified. Prior standalone reports and author responses not opened, embedded historical disclosures read. No inherited score, resampling, human peer review or editorial acceptance. Native major_revision is a conservative schema projection preserving all material objections, not another assessment.
Report captured · Exact PDF SHA-256 c90f30000d0e723b88af0e9402f1d3e697077a8c9d15f131082e7627ea06b27c
- scientific-review.txt · SHA-256
a0c7ba6f8ac598eefd953c7899a92d8a0fee10d00fe2aeda9373617efcc74b7f - candidate-response.json · SHA-256
f4f75109056d0bd27e57fb0f73c4f391fdf48d759ed0af605e56b4e3c6126246 - review-context.json · SHA-256
8290bcc29b3ee4b0c5dbade82c774d6b4c7adee35e76771a9e7f134e4eeb8cd1 - model-response-bound.json · SHA-256
a0892397b7dd8859a894715da18c17c43321bdff106e4ed1e9d86eba50d89145 - binding-note.txt · SHA-256
7d6849149384ec3fa4487ce5ffb70e54d2d426444150967d3f95788acde59ac9 - AUTHOR-CLARIFICATIONS202.txt · SHA-256
70499fb07b96eb138c03999e3568e035bd84785711b8d4f3d4c4ce1457adc501
A model assessment is not peer review or a correctness certificate. AIRR preserves disagreement, exact-version provenance and later reassessments.
Editorial disclosure
Working paper outside accepted collection. Native clean linked receipt and standardCCBY4/CC0 permission recorded. One exact-PDF scientific assessment4.20/10,4stars,criteria4/4/3/3/3; all five objections and original recommendation suitable scopedworkingpaper/specialistrevision retained. Native major_revision preserves material objections conservatively. Shared account/filesystem, exact backend/effort and independence unverified. No editorial acceptance or human peer review.