A channel-by-channel check of the K K-bar eta prediction for X(2370)
Citable version that has not completed AIRR screening. Not peer reviewed. Screening record
We reconstruct seven charge-summed ratios in a constant-amplitude calculation for X(2370). The listed partial widths give 0.0134672 for the K K-bar eta to K K-bar pion ratio, while the published summary gives 0.135. All other entries agree at the printed precision. On the Cartesian product of the quoted mixing-parameter ranges the ratio lies between 0.00548 and 0.02520. A threshold argument explains the spectator dependence of the printed integration measure.
Preview PDF on this page v1
Uses your browser's PDF viewer. Open the PDF directly if a preview is unavailable.
Cite this paper
Lluis Eriksson (2026). A channel-by-channel check of the K K-bar eta prediction for X(2370). AIRR.SCIENCE, ARR-2026-76ZG6Q803S995SEN, v1. https://airr.science/papers/ARR-2026-76ZG6Q803S995SEN/versions/v1/ Research preprint; ARR-2026-76ZG6Q803S995SEN v1. Not peer reviewed by AIRR. Working paper; not admitted to the AIRR accepted collection.
Use this version link to cite the manuscript you read. A Working paper label means the version has not completed AIRR screening. AIRR screening is not journal peer review. Import BibTeX, RIS or CSL JSON into your reference manager to apply a citation style.
Version history
The paper identifier remains stable. Each version has its own immutable release, timestamp and version identifier.
- v1 · source snapshot available · viewing
Verification record
- Frontier-model screening
- Not assessed
- Source integrity
- Pass
- Bibliographic integrity
- Partial
- Reproducibility
- Partial
- Lean 4
- Not applicable
Recorded under ARR-VERIFY-1.0. AIRR verification and screening are not peer review.
AI assistance statement
OpenAI Codex participated in analysis, writing and the first review of the exact PDF. Its shared-context assessment is 3.85/10. Report SHA-256 0eff23df84eb4d0259006b9aeaa1f2a03b0923657b0f1347107589e3e9429d15. The author administers AIRR. Independent peer review has not been documented.
Frontier-model screening
Status: not_assessed. Any listed reports correspond to this exact version under ARR-SCREEN-1.0; no absent assessment is represented as a pass.
Model assessments and review context
- Distinct models
- 1
- Range
- 3.85–3.85
- Method
- bounded capability-weighted mean · exact version only
Limited evidence · 0/1 benchmark matches. This is an evidence description, not a probability of correctness.
Only one distinct model; One provider; shared blind spots possible; Fresh blinded review context not documented for every model; Mathematical benchmark not applied to this subject; Adverse reports or unresolved objections require editorial disposition
OpenAI · gpt-6.2-astra · involved in manuscript · review context: shared3.85
Recommendation: Minor Revision · Material objections: 0
The principal discrepancy survives charge summation, numerical integration and variation over the stated parameter rectangle. Of seven entries one is a fixed normalization, leaving five nontrivial agreement checks and one discrepancy. The spectator limit is a distinct algebraic check on the printed measure. I participated in the analysis and writing in the same context. This assessment concerns the exact two-page PDF.
- Correctness confidence
- Eqs. 27–28 sum to 0.01346718. The orthogonal eta-prime control and remaining nontrivial rows agree with the reported precision. The bound on the mean of 1/sqrt(s) proves the claimed threshold limit for positive masses.
- Rigor
- Sensitivity extrema follow from coordinate monotonicity and the negative sign of the amplitude throughout the rectangle. The three quoted marginal ranges do not define a coverage probability. The scale factors rely on root finding rather than exact interval arithmetic.
- Novelty
- The mismatch and the numerical envelope address a specific contemporary prediction. Invariant phase space and the mixing scheme are standard. A comprehensive priority search for the correction is not documented.
- Significance
- The corrected eta mode would be a materially different experimental benchmark, especially compared with alternative chiral predictions. The note neither measures this mode nor settles the glueball assignment.
- Reproducibility
- Both pages were inspected. Two PDF builds agreed; two pinned calculations reproduced the archived values in Colab. Numerical evidence reproduces the arithmetic under the stated inputs without access to the original implementation.
Strengths
- A direct calculation from the source widths establishes the decimal discrepancy without relying on numerical quadrature.
- Contrasting spectator pairings and the eta-prime channel distinguishes the printed integration measure from the width-table issue.
Weaknesses
- Reporting the central node angle and explicit mass inputs in the text would make the cancellation easier to reconstruct from the paper alone.
- The relative practical differences from alternative predictions in Wang Eq. 31 are not quantified in the note.
Potential errors
- The stated scaling thresholds apply to proportional dilation of this particular parameter rectangle only.
- The discrepancy is internal to one phenomenological model. A nonconstant matrix element, final-state interactions or different mixing inputs can change an experimental prediction.
Strong novelty candidates
- Identification of a unique discrepant nontrivial entry together with a sensitivity envelope incompatible with the printed value.
Unresolved material objections
None reported.
arr:assessment:b0e6a8e4-96e4-4ad3-a924-b53e805111bb · prompt ARR-ASSESS-1.0 · response SHA-256 9835f0346617bab5f920c408aa16cfcef85b4a264a4b498629df5369d6420f01 · canonical PDF SHA-256 eba465d86427ff7ecb1044fc48332fa285b3b77156d2f032590da58a55abeb41
A model assessment is not peer review or a correctness certificate. AIRR preserves disagreement, exact-version provenance and later reassessments.
Editorial disclosure
Working-paper deposit under exact-hash permission. Collection screening and independent peer review remain outstanding.