What would establish a lower cost per surviving mangrove? A finite-population audit of a restoration plan
Citable version that has not completed AIRR screening. Not peer reviewed. Screening record
Using an Indonesian restoration plan with 125,269 proposed seedlings, we derive a one-nursery census threshold and exact worst-case probabilities for prospective audits. In a specified 16-block register, a prespecified test based on 13 established positions in distinct random blocks has maximum false certification probability 0.048812, rounded. Concentrating all visits in a single random block raises the maximum to 0.750441. For product-weight selection of distinct blocks we derive the exact unequal-capacity bound and a sharp symmetric tolerance of 437 positions. A separate sensitivity shows how fixed costs affect a standardized budget comparison. These are planning calculations without field survival observations.
Preview PDF on this page v1
Uses your browser's PDF viewer. Open the PDF directly if a preview is unavailable.
Cite this paper
Lluis Eriksson (2026). What would establish a lower cost per surviving mangrove? A finite-population audit of a restoration plan. AIRR.SCIENCE, ARR-2026-6DPRKPKVYA9PN89M, v1. https://airr.science/papers/ARR-2026-6DPRKPKVYA9PN89M/versions/v1/ Research preprint; ARR-2026-6DPRKPKVYA9PN89M v1. Not peer reviewed by AIRR. Working paper; not admitted to the AIRR accepted collection.
Use this version link to cite the manuscript you read. A Working paper label means the version has not completed AIRR screening. AIRR screening is not journal peer review. Import BibTeX, RIS or CSL JSON into your reference manager to apply a citation style.
Version history
The paper identifier remains stable. Each version has its own immutable release, timestamp and version identifier.
- v1 · source snapshot available · viewing
Verification record
- Frontier-model screening
- Not assessed
- Source integrity
- Pass
- Bibliographic integrity
- Partial
- Reproducibility
- Partial
- Lean 4
- Not applicable
Recorded under ARR-VERIFY-1.0. AIRR verification and screening are not peer review.
AI assistance statement
OpenAI Codex participated in analysis, drafting and assessment in the shared authoring conversation. The first exact-PDF scientific assessment is 4.45/10; its full report has SHA-256 81e40f38856b6b927c4682efe39a004aa00edc0ed0734d9d963162f6b299102c. The author administers AIRR. External peer review has not been established.
Frontier-model screening
Status: not_assessed. Any listed reports correspond to this exact version under ARR-SCREEN-1.0; no absent assessment is represented as a pass.
Model assessments and review context
- Distinct models
- 1
- Range
- 4.45–4.45
- Method
- bounded capability-weighted mean · exact version only
Limited evidence · 0/1 benchmark matches. This is an evidence description, not a probability of correctness.
Only one distinct model; One provider; shared blind spots possible; Fresh blinded review context not documented for every model; Benchmark match incomplete; Adverse reports or unresolved objections require editorial disposition
OpenAI · OpenAI Codex (GPT-6 family, exact serving revision unverified) · involved in manuscript · review context: shared4.45
Recommendation: Minor Revision · Material objections: 0
I inspected all three rendered pages and the version-specific evidence. Sections 3 and 4 show why 13 successful checks in one selected block can coexist with a high probability of a false certification while a prespecified dispersed design controls that probability. The one-nursery reduction has a clear estimand. The arithmetic spending comparison in Section 5 is conditional on an unmeasured cost response. The PDF is legible and suitable as an analytical working paper.
- Correctness confidence
- The economic cut is floor(A N/B)+1. Monotonicity places K survivors in the accessible frame under the least favorable null. The equal-register extremizers sum to 81,618, and the two reported probabilities refer to different randomized designs.
- Rigor
- The product-weight law cancels the capacity factors, and the pair transfer maximizes e_k with upper bounds. In the symmetric band used for the boundary, the maximizing success profile fits even the smallest admissible block. Thus the worst capacity denominator and success numerator are jointly attained.
- Novelty
- Product-weight sampling, hypergeometric probabilities and pair transfers are established. The sharp, case-specific 437-position robustness radius and contrast between spatial observation rules add a reproducible consequence to this proposed budget. General methodological priority is unestablished.
- Significance
- The same number of verified plants can produce radically different evidence depending on the sampling frame. The result can guide planning, but requires a fixed register and horizon and does not estimate field survival or the number of successful audits.
- Reproducibility
- The companion includes count inputs, exact rational probabilities, witnesses and finite exhaustive checks. The source PDF and manuscript are pinned and the latter reproduced twice. There are no implementation data with which to check model fit.
Strengths
- Both least-favorable landscapes are explicit.
- The unequal-capacity argument states the precise subset selection law and gives a way to implement it.
- The prospective use is separated from claims about measured survival.
Weaknesses
- Operating power at realistic intermediate survival levels and travel costs are not quantified.
- The fixed-cost sensitivity uses a benchmark quoted in the source without direct administrative scope verification.
- A small table listing all three designs and their denominators could help practitioners distinguish sampling positions from sampling hectares.
Potential errors
- A frame that omits empty planting positions, replaces inaccessible draws selectively, or uses successive proportional sampling instead of product weights would not realize the stated test.
- A one-sided five-percent test does not make the probability of the null conditional on an observed pass five percent.
- An implemented project could depart from the published budgets and densities and would need a recalculated threshold.
Strong novelty candidates
- Sharp sensitivity of a 13-visit certification to registered block capacities in the specified plan, with matching integer failure witness one position beyond the tolerance.
Unresolved material objections
None reported.
arr:assessment:b05a5b24-7175-4241-a34c-21f552faf757 · prompt ARR-ASSESS-1.0 · response SHA-256 d511de80757a9a36f82f75e34964d5414c7b076721e961d628cf0b68be1cf76d · canonical PDF SHA-256 1620ef52a6b64ae91e7d862d27a106cacc85497a721e7ea3ac5aecf75052d176
A model assessment is not peer review or a correctness certificate. AIRR preserves disagreement, exact-version provenance and later reassessments.
Editorial disclosure
Working-paper deposit under exact-hash permission. Collection screening and independent peer review remain outstanding.