Canonical and unrestricted observations in a finite checkerboard gradient model
Citable version that has not completed AIRR screening. Not peer reviewed. Screening record
We compare unrestricted observations and canonical original-channel rectangle means for a finite two-channel source-weighted checkerboard gradient form. Exact orthogonal restoring ranks and a fixed-positive-angle order-n Fourier construction are retained. We add a constructive every-window corner-matching obstruction for a three-dimensional cyclic product-slice extension. Its nonwrapping product-slice restrictions yield logarithmic necessary counts for fixed or bounded-motion cuts. A rapidly moving cyclic24n-row family fails through a short four-step resonance. Its wrapped complements are not nonwrapping canonical cells, so that failure is not transferred merely by refining means. A separate new cutoff covers the additional chart-boundary corners and constructs a real nonzero actual-coexact field annihilating each of36n-24 nonwrapping refined means, with Q<7c||z||^2/16 at an enormous stated finite threshold. Original counting normalization, source parity, coexact membership, exact zeros and nonzero norm are derived explicitly. The general canonical coexact O(n)-versus-logarithm question remains open. Historical originality and wider quantitative relevance are unestablished; no physical Yang-Mills gap or continuum result follows.
Preview PDF on this page v2
Uses your browser's PDF viewer. Open the PDF directly if a preview is unavailable.
Cite this paper
Lluis Eriksson (2026). Canonical and unrestricted observations in a finite checkerboard gradient model. AIRR.SCIENCE, ARR-2026-597T88D7WZ98HR0Z, v2. https://airr.science/papers/ARR-2026-597T88D7WZ98HR0Z/versions/v2/ Research preprint; ARR-2026-597T88D7WZ98HR0Z v2. Not peer reviewed by AIRR. Working paper; not admitted to the AIRR accepted collection.
Use this version link to cite the manuscript you read. A Working paper label means the version has not completed AIRR screening. AIRR screening is not journal peer review. Import BibTeX, RIS or CSL JSON into your reference manager to apply a citation style.
Version history
The paper identifier remains stable. Each version has its own immutable release, timestamp and version identifier.
Revision statement
Major revision. Add the constructive every-window corner-matching obstruction and a separately constructed actual nonwrapping36n-24-row counterexample, with explicit original coexact preimage, separate observation zeros and paid norm/energy bounds. Retain earlier exact unrestricted ranks and angle results.
Verification record
- Frontier-model screening
- Did not pass
- Source integrity
- Pass
- Bibliographic integrity
- Partial
- Reproducibility
- Partial
- Lean 4
- Not assessed
Recorded under ERIKSSON-EXACT-ARTIFACT-20261031. AIRR verification and screening are not peer review.
AI assistance statement
OpenAI/Codex assisted drafting and involved analytical readings. Exact new397040-byte14-page PDF SHA256f9d3a44e4811a28ec11af3577a4218dad1cb2b3bc0482e2528f5ff80ffdc3892; frozen sourcefb3ba8d2c0ae52d4a2e909b0fb2df02b2f953bc4. Genuine first exact-PDF involved AI importance5.00/10, overall5/10, major_revision; two material objections260C-M1 historical originality and260C-M2 wider quantitative/general relevance remain OPEN. Original criteria correctness4,rigor4,novelty2,significance2,clarity4 of5. A separate narrowly bounded required-criterion supplement supplies reproducibility4/5 from actual build evidence because the parent first protocol mistakenly requested clarity instead of AIRR-required reproducibility; it is not a second scientific/importance sample, and original5.00/5 findings, clarity and objections stay unchanged. All original reports/prompts/responses/context and supplement retained; no old255B4/10 inherited. Actual reviewer identity Codex/OpenAI; exact served backend/model version/effort unavailable. Shared programme/construction/prior reports visible, not blind or independently established or human peer review. All14 actual PDF pages read in text and individually as original PNGs. Two fresh owned-Colab same-source clones produced identicalPDFs;201 inputs,337 members,27 actual inner commands and five actual outer exits verified; own session stopped and backendinactive. Prior scope rejection, ungraded layout-defectiveB, repairs and decoder failure preserved. Source audits are analytical AI readings, not Lean/formal or originality certificates. Proposed one substantial linked Working-paper revision of255B, not a new-paper duplicate or acceptance. Source/review/repro evidence retains original notices and stated limits. Native serialization completion preserves existing judgments; ARR-ASSESS-1.0 is its output contract, not a claim of an original verbatim canonical prompt. Exact protocol and separate times are preserved in format-clarification.txt and full reports.
Frontier-model screening
Status: fail. Any listed reports correspond to this exact version under ARR-SCREEN-1.0; no absent assessment is represented as a pass.
- Codex (exact served backend/model version unavailable)OpenAI · concerns · creation conflict declared
Model assessments and review context
- Distinct models
- 1
- Range
- 5.00–5.00
- Method
- bounded capability-weighted mean · exact version only
Limited evidence · 0/1 benchmark matches. This is an evidence description, not a probability of correctness.
Only one distinct model; One provider; shared blind spots possible; Fresh blinded review context not documented for every model; Benchmark match incomplete; Adverse reports or unresolved objections require editorial disposition
OpenAI · Codex (exact served backend/model version unavailable) · involved in manuscript · review context: unknown5.00
Recommendation: Major Revision · Material objections: 2
The exact14-page PDF is a coherent specialist finite-model manuscript. Fresh analytical checks found no definite fatal error in its actual coexact rank/angle arguments, temporal obstruction or newly constructed nonwrapping36n-24-row counterexample. Importance5.00/10 and overall5/10 are this first exact-new-PDF involved AI judgment, not inherited marks or physical-gap progress. Historical priority and wider quantitative relevance remain open material objections; general canonicalO(n)-versus-logarithm remains open.
- Correctness confidence
- All14 exact PDF pages read in extraction and individually inspected as original PNGs; fresh checks of actual curl adjoint, ranks, angle/domain boundaries, temporal cutoff and separate chart means found no definite fatal error. Involved AI analytical reading only.
- Rigor
- Actual coefficients, counting normalization, coexact potential, observation zeros, nonzero norm and energy constants are explicit. Conservative thresholds and cited inputs retain limits.
- Novelty
- Specialist exact formulas and temporal/chart constructions are plausible novelty candidates; precise historical priority and predecessor implication are unestablished after bounded primary comparison.
- Significance
- Useful finite-model diagnostic, but one parity profile, enormous sufficient thresholds, no general canonical optimum or demonstrated solver/practical consequence.
- Reproducibility
- Two fresh same-SHA clones produced byte-identical397040-byte PDFs;201 frozen inputs,27 actual zero-exit commands,337 raw-manifest members and complete source/tool/log capture support strong within-environment reproduction. Independent external/cross-platform reproduction and a fully version-locked environment remain unestablished.
Strengths
- Explicit original source-weighted form, counting normalization and actual coexact curl-adjoint image.
- Matched exact orthogonal unrestricted rank bounds and scoped fixed-angle order-n construction.
- Ambient canonical argument is not falsely transferred to the coexact domain.
- Temporal window estimates construct an actual real invisible nonzero field with paid energy constants.
- New36n-24 nonwrapping chart result kills every refined mean with added boundary centres; no invalid union-refinement inference.
- Related results are consolidated with clear finite-model and review-context limits.
Weaknesses
- Exact historical originality and predecessor implications remain unestablished.
- General mechanisms are classical and specialist formulas alone do not establish broad significance.
- Huge sufficient thresholds, one parity profile and unresolved general canonical optimum limit quantitative relevance.
- No condition-number theorem, implemented solver or physical spectral gap is obtained.
- Navigation table and minor source-reference/copy-editing improvements remain desirable.
Potential errors
- No definite fatal mathematical error or counterexample was identified within the stated finite hypotheses; this is not formal or exhaustive verification.
- Conjugations and square-root symbols can be obscured in text extraction; actual page images and source confirm them.
- The temporal theorem has constant actual q; the refined chart proof instead explicitly uses six covering tags and does not apply that theorem with a fictitious constant cell count.
- Zero mean on a cyclic union is not enough for its refined pieces; Proposition8.2 constructs a new field to obtain those separate zeros.
Strong novelty candidates
- Exact finite orthogonal ambient/coexact unrestricted rank formulas, subject to historical priority scrutiny.
- The every-window corner-matching obstruction for a scoped product-slice class, with actual coexact field construction.
- The separately constructed moving nonwrapping36n-24-row failure family with paid boundary and energy estimates.
Unresolved material objections
- 260C-M1 | OPEN | material | Historical originality and theorem positioning: No theorem-by-theorem predecessor/implication comparison establishes the exact specialization as a strong stand-alone contribution; bounded primary reading is not a priority proof.
- 260C-M2 | OPEN | material | Wider significance and quantitative usefulness: A narrow parity toy profile, enormous sufficient thresholds and the open general canonical optimum leave broader theoretical/practical relevance unestablished; no implemented solver or condition-number application is demonstrated.
arr:assessment:a22f9dbc-d00b-4b8e-9fdb-5cb2de8e2fa0 · prompt ARR-ASSESS-1.0 · response SHA-256 bbdca0ddbc6c15943b0b4becf4f0eb35981d3806afff3cb88d291d0a68ce54d6 · canonical PDF SHA-256 f9d3a44e4811a28ec11af3577a4218dad1cb2b3bc0482e2528f5ff80ffdc3892
OpenAI · Codex (exact served backend/model version unavailable)
Original AI-only score: 5 / 10 · Scientific importance0-10, overall5/10, five criteria4/4/2/2/4 outof5
major_revision
First exact260C PDF involved assessment; both material objections OPEN. Originality and wider quantitative relevance unestablished. Working-paper publication is not acceptance.
Backend identity: unknown. Nonblind shared programme/construction context; exact served backend/version/effort unavailable. Original custom prompt and clarity4 retained; genuine separately recorded missing-axis reproducibility4. Later format-only ARR-ASSESS-1.0 serialization does not claim an original verbatim canonical prompt or a new assessment. No score or findings edited, no prior255B grade inherited.
Report captured · Exact PDF SHA-256 f9d3a44e4811a28ec11af3577a4218dad1cb2b3bc0482e2528f5ff80ffdc3892
- assessment260C-first-round/scientific-review.txt · SHA-256
e598f628b78db894cc04af1b2148d45d9e262a26cb2f29cddb7f8e90d7b8ec55 - assessment260C-first-round/prompt.txt · SHA-256
88a8ab8b12f82eb5abd443e708d18bb05b5ae4085ef153b7a5b82de98f7c8f06 - assessment260C-first-round/response-native.json · SHA-256
70ae74208f198811c3dcf44c4b3ebf9830c61965b1b03782b5449ccb66ade69f - assessment260C-first-round/review-context.json · SHA-256
cb267e78a5a4aece0f3d72af786c3deee952f06f9e53f23043058ca4f0c45978 - assessment260C-first-round/assignment-readable.txt · SHA-256
5518b857f96a60f855d7c3db181138ac740507b8258d83f529b8c20b46b1ccf9 - assessment260C-first-round/primary-reading-notes.txt · SHA-256
d9e533e861374e49e153ad7c4604f8442d728ef82744892fd10c9c1838dd07ff - assessment260C-first-round/supplemental-retention-hashes.json · SHA-256
1369cbdaefd58d61468e3429d18823fad802ad329b97d26cff511e9c3fd35cf0 - assessment260C-required-reproducibility-supplement/reproducibility-supplement.txt · SHA-256
f16223cd21ed528466b0c91e968331358b601ab36e72316355b4f7bc81043bad - assessment260C-required-reproducibility-supplement/criterion-response.json · SHA-256
385cd4f76d0394951a3a7cf92d361c7786ce9c6683fe2b65773e58fbfd30af2c - assessment260C-required-reproducibility-supplement/review-context.json · SHA-256
5586ea3fda92dc0b537ffbca983996b6bd6690c7412f37e0737cd65e3b95b80e - assessment260C-native-format-completion/format-clarification.txt · SHA-256
5a402d01fd2cff6d303e3c75fd47bfa58f332eb750608de8f92d89e68b11adda - assessment260C-native-format-completion/format-context.json · SHA-256
8042de30601268cba48143bf19fae98b878c53e8dd199d53d0e19967a5b6ecdb - assessment260C-native-format-completion/response-native.json · SHA-256
814553088de3f28c66847e702a7fe6afc25a203ffea29e38661a52194c186769 - author-response260C.txt · SHA-256
f2daac860bba205442f2cfe69c0d0ee2fc19dc72c21dc5cdbde06c5d0f19b8ae
A model assessment is not peer review or a correctness certificate. AIRR preserves disagreement, exact-version provenance and later reassessments.
Editorial disclosure
Linked substantial research Working-paper v2. First involved exact-PDF AI5.00/10, overall5stars, criteria4/4/2/2/4; major_revision, both material objections OPEN. Real native linked receipt and exact CC-BY/CC0 Working-paper permission; no human signoff, acceptance or independent peer review.